The short-term rental market in South Africa, dominated by platforms like Airbnb, has seen significant growth over the past decade, changing the tourism landscape and contributing billions to the economy. However, along with Airbnb's internal policy shift, the recent regulatory changes proposed by the South African government, are poised to restructure this dynamic sector. This article explores the potential impact of these changes on South Africa's tourism economy, housing markets and communities, focusing in particular on Cape Town, the global Airbnb hotspot.
Airbnb is the foundation of South Africa's tourism industry, helping to grow economically and create jobs. In 2022, Airbnb donated R23.5 billion to the South African economy, supporting nearly 50,000 jobs, up 115% from pre-Covid levels. In 2023, it welcomed 700,000 Airbnb guests in Cape Town alone, generating R14.4 billion in GDP and supporting 42,000 jobs. The appeal of the platform is its ability to provide unique and affordable accommodation, allowing hosts to earn supplemental income while meeting the tastes of diverse travelers. However, this rapid expansion has raised concerns about housing affordability, regulatory oversight and competition from the traditional hospitality sector.
Recent changes in the Airbnb ecosystem
1. Proposed government regulations
The South African Tourism Authority has finalised a policy framework to regulate short-term rentals, aiming to balance tourism growth with housing needs. The key suggestions are:
National Host Registration System: Airbnb advocates a national registration system to increase transparency and provide evidence-based regulatory data. The system allows authorities to monitor hosting activities and implement targeting rules when necessary.
Rental date threshold: This framework could strengthen the tourism minister's limiting the number of days he can rent each year, and could limit short-term rentals to maintain long-term housing availability.
Licensing and Compliance Costs: New regulations may require hosts to obtain licenses, comply with zoning laws, meet safety and health standards, and increase operating costs.
These measures address concerns about housing affordability, particularly in Cape Town. Cape Town has skyrocketed 190% since 2022 with over 23,000 active lists. Critics argue that short-term rentals inflate rental prices and make it difficult for locals to compete.
2. Updated Airbnb internal policy
In March 2024, Airbnb removed the 100,000 low-quality list and implemented a global initiative to prioritize high-quality, reliable accommodations. The move, part of the company's “Spring Product Update,” has been enhanced with a more stringent verification process, including photo and video authentication, as well as a “guest favorite” system that highlights a list of top performances. In South Africa, this could affect hosts who do not meet the promoted criteria and could reduce the number of active lists.
Impact on the South African market
1. Tourism economy
The proposed regulations and Airbnb quality crackdowns could have a variety of impacts on the tourism sector in South Africa.
Positive impact:
Improved Trust and Quality: Airbnb may focus on a list of high quality, improving the guest experience and enhancing South Africa's reputation as the best destination. This could attract more international visitors, accounting for 44.74% of Airbnb guests in Cape Town.
Sustainable Tourism: The national registration system can ensure safety and compliance with tax regulations and promote sustainable tourism in line with global trends.
Economic Resilience: By formalizing the short-term rental market, regulations can integrate it into the mainstream tourism economy, stabilize host revenues and support local businesses.
Negative impact:
Reducing host revenue: Rental day limits and increased compliance costs can reduce host revenue. In Cape Town, a typical host earns R74,000 each year from a 38-night booking, with 49% of hosts who rely on their homes in particular potentially at risk.
Loss of market share: Some hosts have reported a decline in Airbnb bookings in Cape Town, with competitors such as Booking.com gaining traction. Strict regulations could push hosts up to alternative platforms and erode Airbnb's advantage.
Investment Uncertainty: Investors can hesitate to enter the short-term rental market due to regulatory uncertainty, which may slow the growth of tourism-related real estate.
2. Housing Market
The surge in the Airbnb list is linked to the affordable housing challenges, particularly in Cape Town. Government regulatory pushes aim to mitigate these issues.
Potential relief for long-term rentals: Limiting short-term rental days will free up property for long-term tenants and ease rental prices pressure. However, Airbnb's research suggests “least or no correlation” between listings and rent increases, pointing to broader factors such as Apartheid's spatial heritage and internalization.
Host challenges: Many hosts, especially small operators, rely on Airbnb to complement their income amid rising costs of living. Formal registration and compliance costs can be a burden on the finances and can force some people to withdraw from the market.
Gentification Concerns: “airbnb'fication” in Cape Town's city centre has been criticized for deepening inequality and driving away residents. Regulations may curb this trend, but enforcement challenges may persist in high-demand regions such as the Atlantic coast.
3. Local Community
This change will also affect the community, especially in areas with high tourism.
Economic Benefits: Airbnb guests often spend time at local businesses, creating ripple effects that support small businesses. In 2023, Cape Town hosts won R2.5 billion, many of which were reinvested locally. Regulations that maintain hosting opportunities can maintain these benefits.
Social tension: The influx of short-term rentals has caused tensions in residential areas, with residents citing noise, safety and community disruption. Registration systems can address these concerns by enabling better monitoring.
Cultural Impact: By promoting authentic, community-based tourism, Airbnb has diversified its travel experiences. However, excessive reliance on short-term rentals runs the risk of transforming neighborhoods into “tourist areas” that undermine the local culture.
Case Study: Cape Town Airbnb Market
Cape Town illustrates both the opportunities and challenges of Airbnb's growth. With 19,114 active listings as of March 2025, the city boasts a median occupancy of 71% and an average daily rate of 1,663 ZAR. Atlantic coasts in particular offer yields of 10-15% per year, well above the 4-7% of long-term rentals. However, the city's housing crisis, exacerbated by internal migration since 2022 and a 190% increase in Airbnb's list, has fueled a request for regulation. The proposed thresholds and registration systems could stabilize the market, but if overly limited there is a risk that attenuates investment and host revenues.
Stakeholder perspective
Hosts: Many hosts, especially small operators, fear that regulations will increase costs and limit income. The 2023 Airbnb Community Post highlighted concerns about formal registration costs and competition with large tourism athletes.
Government: Minister Patricia de Lille emphasizes the need for data-driven regulations to balance tourism and housing needs. The Tourism Bureau's cooperation with Airbnb shows its willingness to work with stakeholders.
Traditional Hospitality: Once a vocal critic, the Federation of Hospitality Association of South Africa (Fedhasa), now supports a balanced approach and recognizes short-term rentals as essential for tourism.
Residents: Cape Town locals express their dissatisfaction with rising rents and community disruption, urging more strict control.
Future outlook
The impact of these changes will depend on the final regulatory framework and its enforcement. A balanced approach (combining the national registration system, rational thresholds, and small host support) can increase transparency and sustainability while maintaining economic benefits. However, excessively strict rules run the risk of suppressing innovation and pushing hosts up to unregulated platforms. Airbnb's quality initiatives can strengthen brands, but marginal hosts can be ruled out, especially in rural areas where there are fewer resources.
Investors must remain cautious, focusing on high-demand areas like the Atlantic seaboard, preparing for compliance costs. Hosts can adapt by prioritizing quality, leveraging Airbnb's verification tools, and diversifying revenues through alternative platforms. For policymakers, collaboration with Airbnb and local stakeholders is important to creating evidence-based regulations that address housing concerns without compromising tourism.
Airbnb's operations and recent changes to the South African regulatory environment mark a pivotal moment for the short-term rental market. These measures aim to address affordability in housing and ensure sustainable tourism, but pose challenges for hosts and investors. By promoting transparency and quality, South Africa can harness the economic potential of Airbnb, while mitigating its social impact and ensuring that the tourism boom will benefit both visitors and locals.
For industry-related news, click here.
